Best Nursing Homes in Smithtown, NY, Graded A–F
All 3 graded Medicare-certified nursing homes in Smithtown, NY, scored from CMS Care Compare — nurse staffing, health inspections, quality measures and penalties — against New York peers of the same size. Grades are computed, never edited, and every input is shown on the facility page.
CMS data as of Aug 2026 · graded Sep 11, 2026Grade distribution — Smithtown, NY
A1
B0
C2
D0
F0
Highest graded
Smithtown · Staffing 3.9 nurse hours per resident-da...See grade
3 facilitiesgraded in Smithtown, NY · 1 earned an A
All New York
Bronx (41)Brooklyn (40)Rochester (23)New York (13)Far Rockaway (12)Flushing (11)Staten Island (10)Buffalo (8)Syracuse (7)
Highest in Smithtown, NY 1
Brookside Multicare Nursing Center - Smithtown, NY · 353 beds · for profit - limited liability company CMS Care Compare · data as of Aug 2026
- Staffing 3.9 nurse hours per resident-day — top quarter in New York
- 3 health deficiencies at the last standard survey (CMS severity score 12) — top quarter
- No fines or payment denials in 3 years
AScore 79 · ExcellentSee Full Grade
6317242200
Smithtown, Suffolk County
Medicaid
2
Smithtown Center For Rehabilitation & Nursing Care - Smithtown, NY · 162 beds · for profit - corporation CMS Care Compare · data as of Aug 2026
- Staffing 3.5 nurse hours per resident-day — above median in New York
- 9 health deficiencies at the last standard survey (CMS severity score 36) — above median
- No fines or payment denials in 3 years
CScore 53 · AverageSee Full Grade
6313612020
Smithtown, Suffolk County
Medicaid
3
St Catherine Of Siena Nursing And Rehabilitation C - Smithtown, NY · 240 beds · non profit - corporation CMS Care Compare · data as of Aug 2026
- Staffing 3.9 nurse hours per resident-day — top quarter in New York
- 5 health deficiencies at the last standard survey (CMS severity score 36) — above median
- $64,496 in fines in 3 years
CScore 52 · AverageSee Full Grade
6318623900
Smithtown, Suffolk County
Medicaid
New York nursing homes by city
How we grade nursing homes
What data goes into a grade?
CMS Care Compare: Nurse staffing (30), Health inspections (30), Quality measures (25), Penalties (15). Each metric is percentile-ranked against New York facilities in the same size band; A ≥ 72, B ≥ 58, C ≥ 42, D ≥ 28, F below. Facilities with under 60% of data are shown as "Not graded".
Can a facility pay to improve its grade?
No. Grades are computed from public data and have no editable field. Nothing on this page is sponsored.
Is a grade a substitute for visiting?
No. Use it to shortlist, then visit, ask for the latest inspection report, and talk to residents' families.