Best Hospitals in Ohio, Graded A–F — page 6
All 138 graded Medicare-certified hospitals in Ohio, scored from CMS Care Compare — overall rating, mortality, safety of care and readmissions — against Ohio hospitals of the same type. Grades are computed, never edited, and every input is shown on the hospital page.
CMS data as of Sep 2026 · graded Sep 11, 2026
All Ohio
Cincinnati (8)Cleveland (6)Columbus (5)Akron (3)Dayton (3)Lima (3)Toledo (3)Beachwood (2)Canton (2)
126
Ohiohealth Mansfield Hospital - Mansfield, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — below median among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
- Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
DScore 31 · Below averageSee Full Grade
(419) 526-8000
Mansfield, RICHLAND County
Emergency dept.
Birthing-Friendly
127
Summa Western Reserve Hospital - Cuyahoga Falls, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - other CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — below median among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 5
- Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
DScore 31 · Below averageSee Full Grade
(330) 971-7000
Cuyahoga Falls, SUMMIT County
Emergency dept.
128
East Ohio Regional Hospital - Martins Ferry, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - other CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — bottom quarter among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
- Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 2
DScore 31 · Below averageSee Full Grade
(740) 633-1100
Martins Ferry, BELMONT County
129
Ashtabula County Medical Center - Ashtabula, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — below median among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 1 worse, of 6
- Safety: 2 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 5
DScore 29 · Below averageSee Full Grade
(440) 997-2262
Ashtabula, ASHTABULA County
Emergency dept.
130
Hmhp St Elizabeth Boardman Health Center - Boardman, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - church CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — bottom quarter among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 7
- Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 1 worse, of 7
DScore 29 · Below averageSee Full Grade
(330) 729-2929
Boardman, MAHONING County
Emergency dept.
Birthing-Friendly
131
Trinity Medical Ctr East &Trinity Medical Ctr West - Steubenville, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - other CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — bottom quarter among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
- Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
FScore 27 · PoorSee Full Grade
(740) 264-7212
Steubenville, JEFFERSON County
Emergency dept.
Birthing-Friendly
132
Lima Memorial Health System - Lima, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - other CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — below median among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
- Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
FScore 27 · PoorSee Full Grade
(419) 998-4731
Lima, ALLEN County
Emergency dept.
Birthing-Friendly
133
Adena Regional Medical Center - Chillicothe, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — below median among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
- Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 2 worse, of 8
FScore 25 · PoorSee Full Grade
(740) 779-7500
Chillicothe, ROSS County
Emergency dept.
Birthing-Friendly
134
Henry County Hospital, Inc - Napoleon, OH · Critical access hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — bottom quarter among Ohio critical access hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
- Readmission: 0 measures better than the national rate, 1 worse, of 5
FScore 21 · PoorSee Full Grade
(419) 592-4015
Napoleon, HENRY County
Emergency dept.
135
Licking Memorial Hospital - Newark, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — bottom quarter among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 7
- Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 7
FScore 21 · PoorSee Full Grade
(740) 348-4000
Newark, LICKING County
Emergency dept.
Birthing-Friendly
136
Trihealth Clinton Regional Hospital - Wilmington, OH · Acute care hospital · government - local CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — bottom quarter among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
- Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 3
FScore 21 · PoorSee Full Grade
(937) 382-9335
Wilmington, CLINTON County
Birthing-Friendly
137
Fairfield Medical Center - Lancaster, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - other CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — bottom quarter among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
- Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 1 worse, of 7
FScore 15 · PoorSee Full Grade
(740) 687-8000
Lancaster, FAIRFIELD County
Emergency dept.
Birthing-Friendly
138
Mount Carmel East & West - Columbus, OH · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026
- CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — bottom quarter among Ohio acute care hospitals
- Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
- Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 2 worse, of 7
FScore 15 · PoorSee Full Grade
(614) 234-5000
Columbus, FRANKLIN County
Emergency dept.
Birthing-Friendly