RankingRight
ElectronicsForm a companyKids Learning AppsLaptopsMattressesOnline CoursesTravel InsuranceVPN ServicesVideo Editing SoftwareAntivirus SoftwareCell Phone PlansHome & kitchenHospitalsLanguage Learning AppsNoise-Cancelling HeadphonesNursing HomesParental Control AppsPhoto Editing SoftwarePillowsSoftware & AppsWeb HostingBaby MonitorsDomain RegistrarsEducationHomework Help & Study ToolsPassword ManagersPayrollCRMFamily & KidsJob Search SitesSTEM Kits for KidsPayments & POSTravel & eSIMWebsite Builders How We Rank How We Make Money Search
Home / Hospitals / New York

Best Hospitals in New York, Graded A–F — page 2

All 138 graded Medicare-certified hospitals in New York, scored from CMS Care Compare — overall rating, mortality, safety of care and readmissions — against New York hospitals of the same type. Grades are computed, never edited, and every input is shown on the hospital page.

CMS data as of Sep 2026 · graded Sep 11, 2026
All New York New York (11)Brooklyn (10)Bronx (6)Buffalo (5)Rochester (4)Syracuse (4)Albany (3)Binghamton (2)Flushing (2)
26

St Charles Hospital - Port Jefferson, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - church CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 5 of 5 — top 10% among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
  • Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
BScore 68 · GoodSee Full Grade
(631) 474-6000 Port Jefferson, SUFFOLK County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
27

Garnet Health Medical Center - Middletown, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 4 of 5 — top quarter among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 2 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
  • Safety: 2 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
BScore 68 · GoodSee Full Grade
(845) 343-2424 Middletown, ORANGE County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
28

Cobleskill Regional Hospital - Cobleskill, NY · Critical access hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 4 of 5 — top quarter among New York critical access hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
  • Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 1
BScore 68 · GoodSee Full Grade
(518) 254-3456 Cobleskill, SCHOHARIE County Emergency dept.
29

Metropolitan Hospital Center - New York, NY · Acute care hospital · government - local CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 2
  • Safety: 2 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 5
BScore 67 · GoodSee Full Grade
(212) 423-6262 New York, NEW YORK County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
30

Phelps Hospital - Sleepy Hollow, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 4 of 5 — top quarter among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
  • Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 7
BScore 65 · GoodSee Full Grade
(914) 366-3000 Sleepy Hollow, WESTCHESTER County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
31

Mount Sinai South Nassau - Oceanside, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 3 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 7
  • Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
BScore 65 · GoodSee Full Grade
(516) 632-3000 Oceanside, NASSAU County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
32

Upstate New York Va Healthcare System (Western Ny Va Healthcare System) - Buffalo, NY · Acute care hospital · veterans health administration CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 5 of 5 — top 10% among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 2 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 5
  • Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
BScore 64 · GoodSee Full Grade
(716) 862-3611 Buffalo, ERIE County Emergency dept.
33

Staten Island University Hospital - Staten Island, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 2 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
  • Safety: 4 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
BScore 63 · GoodSee Full Grade
(418) 226-9761 Staten Island, RICHMOND County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
34

Strong Memorial Hospital - Rochester, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
  • Safety: 2 measures better than the national rate, 1 worse, of 7
BScore 62 · GoodSee Full Grade
(585) 275-2121 Rochester, MONROE County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
35

Va New York Harbor Healthcare System - Brooklyn - Brooklyn, NY · Acute care hospital · veterans health administration CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 4 of 5 — top quarter among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 2 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
  • Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
BScore 61 · GoodSee Full Grade
(718) 836-6600 Brooklyn, KINGS County Emergency dept.
36

Montefiore Medical Center - Bronx, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 5 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
  • Safety: 2 measures better than the national rate, 1 worse, of 8
BScore 61 · GoodSee Full Grade
(718) 920-4321 Bronx, BRONX County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
37

Community Memorial Hospital, Inc - Hamilton, NY · Critical access hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 4 of 5 — top quarter among New York critical access hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
  • Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 1
BScore 60 · GoodSee Full Grade
(315) 824-1100 Hamilton, MADISON County Emergency dept.
38

Elizabethtown Community Hospital - Elizabethtown, NY · Critical access hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 4 of 5 — top quarter among New York critical access hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
  • Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 1
BScore 60 · GoodSee Full Grade
(518) 873-6377 Elizabethtown, ESSEX County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
39

Ellis Hospital - Schenectady, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
  • Safety: 3 measures better than the national rate, 1 worse, of 6
BScore 60 · GoodSee Full Grade
(518) 243-4196 Schenectady, SCHENECTADY County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
40

Kaleida Health - Buffalo, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 1 measure better than the national rate, 1 worse, of 8
  • Safety: 3 measures better than the national rate, 1 worse, of 8
BScore 60 · GoodSee Full Grade
(716) 859-8620 Buffalo, ERIE County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
41

Ns/Lij Hs Southside Hospital - Bay Shore, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
  • Safety: 3 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
BScore 59 · GoodSee Full Grade
(631) 968-3000 Bay Shore, SUFFOLK County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
42

Putnam Hospital Center - Carmel, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 5
  • Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 2
BScore 59 · GoodSee Full Grade
(914) 279-5711 Carmel, PUTNAM County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
43

Northport Va Medical Center - Northport, NY · Acute care hospital · veterans health administration CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 5 of 5 — top 10% among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 3
  • Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 3
CScore 58 · AverageSee Full Grade
(516) 261-4400 Northport, SUFFOLK County Emergency dept.
44

Jones Memorial Hospital - Wellsville, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 4 of 5 — top quarter among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
  • Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 2
CScore 57 · AverageSee Full Grade
(585) 593-1100 Wellsville, ALLEGANY County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
45

St Anthony Community Hospital - Warwick, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - church CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 4 of 5 — top quarter among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 5
  • Safety: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 3
CScore 57 · AverageSee Full Grade
(845) 986-2276 Warwick, ORANGE County Birthing-Friendly
46

Mount Sinai Beth Israel - New York, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 3 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 7
  • Safety: 2 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
CScore 57 · AverageSee Full Grade
(212) 420-2000 New York, NEW YORK County Emergency dept.
47

Queens Hospital Center - Jamaica, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - other CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — below median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 5
  • Safety: 2 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
CScore 56 · AverageSee Full Grade
(718) 883-3000 Jamaica, QUEENS County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
48

Guthrie Cortland Regional Medical Center - Cortland, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 5
  • Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 4
CScore 56 · AverageSee Full Grade
(607) 756-3501 Cortland, CORTLAND County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
49

Highland Hospital - Rochester, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 3 of 5 — above median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
  • Safety: 1 measure better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
CScore 56 · AverageSee Full Grade
(585) 341-6711 Rochester, MONROE County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
50

Mercy Hospital Of Buffalo - Buffalo, NY · Acute care hospital · voluntary non-profit - private CMS Care Compare · data as of Sep 2026

  • CMS overall rating 2 of 5 — below median among New York acute care hospitals
  • Mortality: 0 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 8
  • Safety: 3 measures better than the national rate, 0 worse, of 6
CScore 56 · AverageSee Full Grade
(716) 826-7000 Buffalo, ERIE County Emergency dept. Birthing-Friendly
1 2 3 4 25 per page · page 2+ noindex

New York hospitals by city