DBelow average · score 38/100 · #438 of 593 in New York
Our Lady Of Consolation Nursing And Rehabilitive C
111 Beach Drive, West Islip, NY 11795 · 450 certified beds · Non profit - Corporation
Staffing 3.7 nurse hours per resident-dayabove median in New York
15 health deficiencies at the last standard survey (CMS severity score 80)bottom quarter
$141,980 in fines in 3 years
Why Our Lady Of Consolation Nursing And Rehabilitive C is graded D
Each metric below is percentile-ranked against New York nursing homes in the same size band (large, 450 beds), then weighted. The score is the weighted sum; A ≥ 72, B ≥ 58, C ≥ 42, D ≥ 28, F below. Nothing here can be edited or paid for.
Our Lady Of Consolation Nursing And Rehabilitive C at a Glance
D
38/100
Nurse staffing · weight 30Total nurse hours per resident per day, as reported to CMS (PBJ). Raw: 3.73 h.
71<small style="font-size:12px;color:var(--muted)">th pct</small>Health inspections · weight 30Health deficiencies cited at the last standard survey and complaint surveys, weighted by severity. Raw: 80.
20<small style="font-size:12px;color:var(--muted)">th pct</small>Quality measures · weight 25CMS quality-measure rating: falls, pressure ulcers, rehospitalisation, antipsychotic use. Raw: 4.
43<small style="font-size:12px;color:var(--muted)">th pct</small>Penalties · weight 15Fines and payment denials in the last three years. Raw: $141,980 fines, 0 denials.
4<small style="font-size:12px;color:var(--muted)">th pct</small>CMS overall star ratingMedicare's own 1–5 rating, shown for reference; not part of our grade.
2/5Data: CMS Care Compare, as of Aug 1, 2026 · graded Sep 11, 2026 · peer group: New York, large facilities · CMS record 335539 · How we grade.
Facility details
Address111 Beach Drive, West Islip, NY 11795
Phone6315871600
CountySuffolk
OwnershipNon profit - Corporation
Certified beds450
AcceptsMedicare Medicaid
Special Focus FacilityNo
Higher-graded nursing homes nearby
1
Jefferson's Ferry - South Setauket, NY · 60 beds
- Staffing 5.3 nurse hours per resident-day — top 10% in New York
- No health deficiencies at the last standard survey — top 10%
1
Sunshine Children's Home And Rehab Center - Ossining, NY · 122 beds
- Staffing 9.7 nurse hours per resident-day — top 10% in New York
- 1 health deficiencies at the last standard survey (CMS severity score 4) — top 10%
1
Elizabeth Seton Children's Center - Yonkers, NY · 169 beds
- Staffing 11.1 nurse hours per resident-day — top 10% in New York
- 2 health deficiencies at the last standard survey (CMS severity score 8) — top 10%
A grade is a shortlist tool, not medical or legal advice. Visit the facility, ask for the latest survey report, and talk to residents' families before choosing.